Is It Smart to Buy an Investment Property? Key Questions to Ask First

Thinking about buying a rental property? Certified financial planner Douglas Boneparth shares the 4 essential questions to test whether becoming a landlord fits your budget and goals—plus quick tips to boost your credit score first.
Is It Smart to Get an Investment Property?
Buying a rental property and stepping into the role of a landlord can be a powerful wealth-building strategy—or an expensive headache. Either way, one reality rarely changes: owning rental real estate is a hands-on job, not effortless passive income.
Certified financial planner Douglas Boneparth, founder of Bone Fide Wealth and coauthor of Money Together, notes that anyone promising guaranteed returns in real estate is usually trying to sell you something. While buying an investment property can pay off through steady rental cash flow, long-term property appreciation, and tax benefits like depreciation, social media highlight reels often gloss over the day-to-day grind of vacancies, middle-of-the-night maintenance calls, surprise repairs, and difficult tenant issues.
4 Questions to Answer Before Buying a Rental Property
Before making an offer on an investment property, Boneparth recommends stress-testing both your finances and your mindset against four honest questions:
| Readiness Check | What You Need to Evaluate |
| 1. Vacancy Cushion | Can you comfortably pay the mortgage out of pocket if the unit sits vacant for two to three months between tenants? |
| 2. Repair Liquidity | Do you have enough liquid cash reserves to absorb a major unexpected repair (like a roof leak or HVAC failure) without derailing your broader financial plan? |
| 3. True Cash Flow | In your target market, does realistic market rent cover the mortgage, property taxes, insurance, and ongoing maintenance—with genuine profit left over? |
| 4. Genuine Motivation | Are you buying because rental real estate aligns with your long-term financial strategy, or simply because owning property sounds impressive at dinner parties? |
When conservative math works in your favor and you are prepared for landlord responsibilities, real estate can be a strong addition to your portfolio. If you have to rely on best-case assumptions just to break even on paper, walking away is usually the smarter financial move.
Bonus Tip: How to Quickly Boost Your Credit Score Before Applying for a Mortgage
Because investment property mortgages often carry stricter underwriting and higher interest rates than primary residences, strengthening your credit profile beforehand can save thousands in borrowing costs.
One of the fastest ways to raise your credit score is by lowering your credit utilization rate—the percentage of your total available credit card limit you are currently using. For instance, carrying $15,000 in balances across $30,000 in combined credit limits puts your utilization at 50%, whereas paying those balances down to $5,000 drops your ratio to roughly 17%.
Aim to keep your overall credit utilization below 30% using four practical moves:
-
Pay Down Existing Balances: Reduce revolving card debt ahead of your application and make every payment on time.
-
Pause Large Card Purchases: Avoid putting major expenses on credit cards while shopping for a loan, and pay off routine charges immediately.
-
Keep Old Accounts Open: Closing unused credit cards shrinks your total available credit limit, which can inadvertently push your utilization ratio higher.
-
Hold Off on New Credit Applications: Avoid triggering new lender “hard inquiries” right before a mortgage review (checking your own credit report for errors counts as a soft inquiry and will not hurt your score).
Frequently Asked Questions
Is buying an investment property a good way to build wealth?
Yes, when the numbers work conservatively. Rental properties can build wealth through monthly cash flow, property appreciation, and tax deductions like depreciation—provided you have cash reserves for vacancies and repairs.
How much cash reserve should you have before buying a rental property?
According to financial planner Douglas Boneparth, you should have enough liquid savings to cover at least two to three months of mortgage payments during vacancies plus funds for major unexpected repairs without straining your personal budget.
What is a good credit utilization rate when applying for a loan?
Keeping your credit utilization rate below 30% across your credit cards is ideal, as lower utilization can quickly improve your credit score and help you qualify for better mortgage interest rates.

